Proposal view
Proposal Type: Individual Paper 
Domain: Teaching and Instructional Design 
SIG: Moral and Democratic Education 
Type Submitted Paper 
Equipment PC and projector
Paper Details
Title Long-term effects of peace education programs in the context of intractable conflict
Abstract

Peace education (PE) programs that take place in regions of ongoing conflict face socio-political environment that for many decades cultivated negative perceptions, attitudes, beliefs and emotions towards the adversary. Can PE programs stand a chance for changing the psychological foundation that fueled the conflict through the years? The present study examined the possible differential changes in central and peripheral beliefs as a function of Jewish and Palestinian youngsters' participation in a PE program. Furthermore, this study examined the durability of the educational impact on the youngsters and affectivity of an "induced-compliance" activity to achieve more long-term impact of the program.  


Nine hundred fifty six adolescents participated in this study: About a half of the youth participated in a yearlong school-based PE, when the other half served as a control group. Repeated measurement assessment based on self-report questionnaires implemented in this study. Findings showed that PE program could effectively influence adolescents' peripheral attitudes and beliefs, while the roadblocks of peace education pertain to the core beliefs that stand in the center of the groups' collective narratives. However, peripheral attitudes and beliefs that are more easily affected by PE programs changed back as easily by adverse social and political influences. Additional finding was that an "induced compliance" activity which developed in the present study could promote more long-term impact of the educational influences of a PE program. The results of this study can promote better understanding of the possibilities and the limits of peace education within societies engaged in intractable conflict, and also the ways to overcome these limits.

Summary

Peace education (PE) in the context of intractable conflict involves conflicting collective narratives and underlying attitudes and beliefs. The collective narratives of the conflict embedded into everyday life: media, culture, national and religious festivals, and educational systems. They provide common platform for functioning under the conditions of protracted conflict (Rouhana, & Bar-Tal, 1998; Bar-Tal, & Salomon, in press). Could it be that PE programs in regions of intractable conflict can influence only on more peripheral attitudes and beliefs related to the collective narrative of the conflict while initial central/core beliefs remain without change? These central beliefs are more accessible, more stable over time, more likely to influence behavior, and less susceptible to change (e.g. Abelson, 1988; Petty & Krosnick, 1995). More central collective beliefs are perceived by the relevant society as more important beliefs, compared to the peripheral beliefs.



The present study examined an immediate (a morning after) and more long-term impact of PE programs on central and peripheral beliefs related to the collective narrative of the conflict among Jewish and Palestinian youth. Furthermore, the present study examined the affectivity of an "induced-compliance" activity to achieve more long-term impact of the program. Induced-compliance activity is a procedure based on principles deduced from dissonance theory (Festinger, 1957, Harmon-Jones & Mills, 1999). Induced Compliance (IC) requires program participants to publicly present to their peers the point of view of the opponent, and thus come to align his or her views with those publicly presented as well as discover relatively novel ideas in the opponent's perspective.



The hypotheses of this study were as follows:


1. Peace education programs influence more peripheral attitudes and beliefs based on collective narratives of the groups and less on the central attitudes and beliefs.


2. If peace education programs influence more peripheral attitudes and beliefs, then these attitudes and beliefs will change back after a few months, following the adverse social and political environmental influences. 


3. Participation in IC activity a few months following participation in peace education rehabilitates the changes affected by the program.




Method


 


The study was based on a quasi-experimental factorial design of 2 (nationalities – Israeli-Jewish or Palestinian citizens of Israel) x 2 (participation or non-participation in the peace education program) x 2 (participation or non-participation in an IC activity) with a pretest-posttest-delayed posttest questionnaire that attempted to assess the participants' attitudes and beliefs in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.


Nine hundred fifty six 10th grade adolescents participated in this study. In phase 1 of the study about a half of the youth participated in a year long school-based PE program 'Pathways into Reconciliation' (IPCRI, 2004), when the other half served as a control group. In phase 2 of the study small group of youth which participated in PE program, participated two months later in an IC activity.  




Results and discussion


 


The first hypothesis of the study, according to which peace education programs influence more peripheral attitudes and beliefs based on collective narratives of the groups and less on the central attitudes and beliefs, was confirmed. Peace education programs can't influence significantly on the beliefs that stand in the center of the collective narrative (e.g., Balfour declaration; 1948 and 1967 wars, Palestinian refugees). On the other hand, the research showed that more peripheral beliefs and attitudes (e.g. stereotypes, prejudices and negative emotions) can more easily be changed through a peace education program. As found in this study the PE programs have an immediate impact on the perceived importance of the peripheral beliefs. Jewish youth changed significantly their perceived importance of Palestinian peripheral beliefs about the conflict, compared to more central beliefs as a result of their participation in PE program  [ (F (1,369) = 25.6, p < .001) vs. (F (1,369) = 4.83, p < .05) ]. In addition, Palestinian youth changed significantly their perceived importance of Jewish peripheral beliefs about the conflict, compared to more central beliefs as a result of their participation in PE program  [ (F (1,142) = 21.1, p < .001) vs. (F (1,142) = 0.31, ns. ) ]. The perceived importance of the other narrative of Palestinian and Jewish control group (youth that didn't participate in the PE program) didn't change significantly during this period of time.


The second hypothesis of the study, according to which changed attitudes and beliefs will change back after a few months, following the adverse social and political environmental influences, was confirmed. Two months after the participation in the peace education program this study found that the significant part of changed attitudes and beliefs of the Jewish and Palestinian participants changed back to their initial level.


 


According to the fourth hypothesis of the study, participation in "induced compliance" activity a few months after the participation in a peace education program will rehabilitate the educational changes in attitudes and beliefs that were achieved following the program, was confirmed. The study showed that the youngsters that participated in an "induced compliance" activity improved their positive attitudes and beliefs about the "other" narrative of the conflict.


In summary, the present study showed that peace education programs can effectively influence youngsters' peripheral attitudes and beliefs, while the roadblocks of peace education pertain to the core beliefs that stand in the center of the groups' collective narratives. However, peripheral attitudes and beliefs that are more easily affected by peace education programs changed back as easily by adverse social and political influences. Role-play "induced compliance" based activity can rehabilitate the educational influences of the program. This research is important in terms of theory, policy and practice. The results of this study can promote better understanding of the possibilities and the limits of peace education within societies engaged in intractable conflict, and also the ways to overcome these limits.


___________


This article is based on doctoral dissertation submitted to the University of Haifa, Faculty of Education by the author. Prof. Gavriel Salomon directed the work. 




 



Keywords Beliefs
Moral education/development
Program evaluation
Appendices
Authors
Name Surname Institution Country e-mail EARLI Number Presenting
Yigal Rosen University of Haifa Israel igal.rosen@gmail.com   *  
Visit NQcontent
© European Association for Research on Learning and Instruction, 2012 All rights reserved.